In a message released on November 25, Pope Francis emphasized that the Final Document from the recently concluded Synod on Synodality represents authoritative Church teaching. The pontiff’s note confirmed the document’s significance as a direct reflection of the discernment and discussions held throughout the synodal process, highlighting its essential role in guiding the Church’s life and mission moving forward.
Pope Francis wrote, “Acknowledging the value of the synodal journey that we have made, I now hand over the instructions contained in the Final Document to the entire Church, as a restitution of everything that has matured over these years through listening and discernment, and as an authoritative indication for its life and mission.” The pope further emphasized the importance of the document, declaring, “The Final Document participates in the ordinary Magisterium of the Successor of Peter and thus I ask that it be accepted as such,” a reference to the Church’s teaching authority.
The Synod on Synodality was a multi-year consultation involving Catholics from all levels of the Church. It included discussions at parish levels, continental assemblies of bishops, and two major gatherings in Rome with bishops, religious leaders, and lay Catholics, including both men and women. The synodal process, which started in 2021, focused on developing a more inclusive, transparent, and welcoming Church, based on input from a wide range of Church members around the world.
During the final session of the Synod, held in October 2023 and again this October, participants voted on a final document that was swiftly ratified by Pope Francis on October 26. This document includes several key recommendations aimed at restructuring the Church to be more collaborative and accountable. It advocates for a more horizontal leadership structure, increased accountability for bishops, and greater involvement of laypeople in decision-making processes, all of which are now considered official Church doctrine.
Brian Flanagan, an ecclesiologist and senior fellow at New Ways Ministry, a Catholic LGBTQ outreach organization, commented on the significance of the pope’s note, stating, “The final document is official, magisterial teaching, and so no one can say that following the synodal path is optional.” Flanagan also noted that while local churches have the freedom to adapt the synodal recommendations to their specific cultural and local contexts, the overall approach outlined in the document is binding across the global Church.
However, some of the more contentious issues raised during the synodal discussions—such as the role of women and LGBTQ Catholics—were not fully addressed in the Final Document. These topics were instead assigned to 10 study groups consisting of theologians, canon lawyers, and experts who will present their findings in 2025. Many individuals, especially those advocating for the inclusion of women in the diaconate (a form of holy orders), expressed disappointment that the Synod did not advance further reforms in this area.
Pope Francis acknowledged the need for adaptation in applying the teachings of the Final Document, especially in a global Church that serves over 1.3 billion Catholics. In his note, he explained, “Local churches and groups of churches are now called to enact, within the various contexts, the authoritative indications contained in the document.” He also stressed that the synodal process is ongoing, stating that the conclusion of the Vatican Synod in October does not mark the end of this journey.
Flanagan, commenting on the approach of the Synod, remarked, “Pope Francis is trying to foster greater freedom of further discernment in a global ‘church of churches’ that is too diverse and complex for a heavy-handed, one-size-fits-all approach.” This remark reflects the pope’s desire to encourage a more flexible approach to implementing synodal recommendations, allowing for diversity in the ways different regions of the Church might respond to the teachings.
Pope Francis also indicated that the document provides guidance on how to implement its proposals. He noted that many of the reforms outlined in the document would involve applying existing canon law rather than creating entirely new laws. However, local churches are encouraged to develop new ministries and missionary roles where necessary and share their experiences with the Vatican for further reflection and guidance.
Regarding the relationship between local churches and the Vatican, the pope emphasized that national bishops will be expected to report on the implementation of the synodal recommendations during their five-year “ad limina” visits to the Vatican. “Each bishop will make sure to report which choices were made at his local church regarding what is contained in the final document, which challenges they faced, and what were the fruits,” Pope Francis said. This system of accountability aims to ensure that the synodal teachings are being effectively applied at the local level.
In addition, the pope confirmed that the General Secretariat of the Synod, along with other Vatican departments, will oversee the process and ensure that all national churches participate in the ongoing synodal journey. This will involve facilitating communication between local churches and the Vatican to track progress and challenges in implementing the recommendations outlined in the Final Document.
The Synod on Synodality has sparked both excitement and criticism within the Church, with many lauding the focus on inclusivity and collaboration while others remain cautious about the pace of reform. The pope’s affirmation of the synodal recommendations as official Church teaching indicates his commitment to moving the Church forward in a way that reflects the diverse realities of the global Catholic community. As the Church continues to grapple with the implications of these changes, the synodal process remains a key part of Pope Francis’s broader vision for a more open, accountable, and participatory Church.
The pope’s note underscores the importance of the Synod’s Final Document as an integral part of Church teaching, inviting all Catholics to engage with its directives as part of the ongoing journey of discernment and renewal. With the inclusion of diverse voices from around the world and an emphasis on local adaptation, the Synod has set the stage for continued growth and transformation within the Catholic Church.