The Rev. Winnie Varghese has become the first woman elected to lead the Cathedral Church of St. John the Divine in New York City, marking a significant milestone for diversity and inclusion within the Episcopal Church.
The announcement of Varghese’s appointment as dean was marked by her emotional moment on the steps of the historic cathedral, a place that has loomed large in her imagination since her childhood in Dallas. Reflecting on her new role, Varghese expressed her awe at the responsibility and the vision she holds for the church community.
“What a beautiful responsibility it is to have to think about how to care for people and how to care for community,” Varghese remarked during an interview on July 14. Her involvement with the cathedral began with its evocative depiction in a local newspaper article she read at age 12, which introduced her to its vibrant St. Francis Day celebration.
Varghese officially assumed her new role as dean on July 1, becoming the first woman to lead the largest Episcopal cathedral in the U.S. The appointment of Varghese, a queer woman of Indian descent, signifies the Episcopal Church’s ongoing commitment to progressive values, particularly regarding LGBTQ inclusion and racial justice.
A prominent voice in support of marginalized communities, Varghese has been active in advocating for LGBTQ+ rights and racial equality and has served as a rector in New York City and Atlanta. Her leadership qualities are well recognized, reflecting the Episcopal Church’s intention to widen its embrace of diversity.
The Rev. Kelly Brown Douglas, who co-chaired the search committee for the dean, hailed Varghese as a trailblazer. Douglas emphasized the impact of Varghese’s competence and strength, stating that her leadership would break new grounds for the church.
Prior to her appointment as dean, Varghese served as rector of St. Luke’s Episcopal Church in Atlanta. Her journey in ministry has been marked by firsts and challenges, stepping into roles typically not envisioned for a queer woman of color within the church. According to statistics from the Church Pension Group from 2011 to 2021, only a small fraction of Episcopal priests were women of color.
The journey has come with unexpected hurdles. Varghese recalled past struggles in embracing her identity within the church, further underscoring the significance of her current role. Ordained in 2000, she has been a pioneering figure, reshaping traditional perceptions and practices within her communities.
The position of dean at St. John the Divine is not without challenges, as Varghese steps into her role during a politically charged environment in New York. Issues such as immigration policies and declining church attendance weigh heavily on religious leaders across the city. Varghese is familiar with these challenges, having previously addressed them in her role at St. Mark’s Church in-the-Bowery.
Her approach involves fostering a sense of outreach and welcome, encouraging parishioners to engage with their broader community. The vision of church as an inclusive, inviting space is core to her leadership philosophy as she takes on the task of revitalizing the cathedral’s congregational life.
The Cathedral Church of St. John the Divine, with its storied history intertwined with New York City’s cultural landscape, seeks to continue its tradition of being a hub for music, art, and social engagement. It has been a venue for various artistic presentations, from contemporary art installations to music performances.
In her role, Varghese will also oversee the upkeep of the cathedral’s expansive and unfinished structure. Significant projects, such as the $4 million restoration of the cathedral’s west wall, are underway. Varghese is committed to sustaining the physical and spiritual vibrancy of the cathedral, inviting supporters to invest in its mission.
Her ultimate goal is to continue building on the legacy of St. John the Divine, ensuring the cathedral remains a space of reflection, tradition, and opportunity. On September 27, Varghese will be formally installed as the dean, followed by leading the annual St. Francis Day Blessing of the Animals, embodying the cathedral’s tradition of openness and celebration.